Comparison of Franklin France ESE air terminal models
This table compares the three Franklin France ESE air terminal families, ACTIVE 1D+, ACTIVE 2D and ACTIVE 4D, by model, early streamer emission time ΔT, operating method, testing and monitoring features, and installation details. It helps designers and clients see the differences between models at a glance and, when buying an ESE air terminal, pick the right option for the project to examine more closely.
Compare the performance, models, and testing and monitoring features of the three ACTIVE families at a glance.
Comparing Electronic Lightning Rod Models
For a faster decision, compare each model's key features in one readable table.
| Feature | ACTIVE 1D+ ESE air terminalThe newest, simplest and most varied Franklin France ESE air terminal in terms of early streamer emission time ΔT | ACTIVE 2D ESE air terminalA more advanced model than ACTIVE 1D+ that uses two devices, Impulse and Power, to create and propagate the upward leader (Upward Leader) | ACTIVE 4D ESE air terminalMore advanced than ACTIVE 2D, predicting an approaching storm from 30 km away, logging data in LMS software and with a lightning counter built into the device |
|---|---|---|---|
| Country of Manufacture | Franklin France | Franklin France | Franklin France |
| Air terminal type | New-generation ESE air terminal | ESE air terminal with dual system | Connected lightning protection and monitoring system |
| Operating technology | Internal mechanism triggered by the electric field of the storm | Two methods of creating and propagating the upward leader, using two devices, Impulse and Power | Dual 2D technology with storm monitoring and communication system |
| Early streamer emission time ΔT | 12, 25, 45 or 60 microseconds | 30 or 60 microseconds | 30 or 60 microseconds |
| Main standard | NF C 17-102:2011 | NF C 17-102:2011 | NF C 17-102:2011 |
| Protection radius Rp | Depends on ΔT, installation height and protection level I to IV | Depends on ΔT, installation height and protection level I to IV | Depends on ΔT, installation height and protection level I to IV |
| Energy source | No external power: uses the natural corona effect | From the electrostatic field of the storm, solar cells and power capacitors (no external power)Impulse and Power Devices | From the electrostatic field of the storm, solar cells and power capacitors (no external power)Impulse and Power Devices |
| On-site function test | YesOnly with the wired tester on a telescopic mast | YesWith the remote tester, wireless, from 100 m away | YesWith the Activ’Control unit, wireless, from 100 m away |
| Standard test method | AFV0050TT wired tester; AFV0087PT test pole can be used | Remote radio tester; also wired tester and test pole | Radio test, or test through Activ’Control and LMS software |
| Test from ground level | With a telescopic pole, up to a height of about 8 m | Yes, without opening the device and from 100 m away | Yes, remotely through the control system, from 100 m away |
| Lightning counter | Yes, supplied separately | Yes, supplied separately | Lightning counter built into the device |
| Logging of lightning strike details | Advanced detail logging not included | Advanced detail logging not included | Logs the number, date, time, magnitude, waveform and energy of the lightning currents captured, stored in LMS software |
| Approaching storm detector | Standalone storm warning not included | Standalone storm warning not included | Integrated advanced storm detection and warning system |
| Real-time monitoring and display | No | No | Yes: lightning data and system and device status shown online |
| Controller and software | Not required | Standalone radio tester | Activ’Control controller + LMS software |
| Weight | 2.2 kg | 5.2 kg | 5.2 kg |
| Device height | 490 mm | 1000 mm | 1000 mm |
| Maximum device diameter | 120 mm | 250 mm | 250 mm |
| Body material | 304L stainless steel body and nickel-plated copper strike tip | Stainless steel | Stainless steel |
| Model names | Active 1D+12-Active 1D+25-Active 1D+45-Active 1D+60 | Active2D 30 - Active2D 60 | Active4D 30 - Active4D 60 |
The table is based on the manufacturer's technical documents. The protection radius of each model must be calculated for the specific project to NF C 17-102, according to the protection level and installation height. For your convenience, the coverage radius table for each model, at different protection levels and heights and for the ΔT of that device, is on the page introducing that device.
Website membership required
Sign in or joinHave a Technical Question?
KALOT Group's technical experts are ready to answer your questions about lightning rods and earthing systems.



